Obsolescence of sludge tank level instrumentation presents a complex challenge for nuclear power stations, where accurate measurement depends on detecting different materials within the same tank. The difficulty lies in identifying replacement technologies that can reliably distinguish between multiple media interfaces while operating within demanding process conditions. AMS Nuclear combines specialist instrumentation knowledge with practical engineering expertise to develop solutions that address these challenges, using commercially available technologies wherever possible to support long-term maintainability and reduce obsolescence risk.
At Torness Power Station (EDF Energy), the existing multi-probe level measurement system within the Active Effluent Treatment Plant (AETP) required a sustainable replacement. AMS Nuclear undertook a comprehensive optioneering and proof-of-concept testing programme, evaluating different measurement technologies and developing a bespoke probe assembly capable of accommodating multiple instruments.
Working to EDF’s Quality Assurance Grade 3 requirements, AMS Nuclear designed a representative test facility to assess instrument performance across different media, including ion exchange resins, sand, anthracite and sludge. The programme identified a combination of technologies suitable for further development, providing an evidence-based approach to modernisation with potential application across the wider EDF fleet.
Ensuring Reliable Effluent Monitoring in a Highly Regulated Environment
Effluent management systems are fundamental to the safe and compliant operation of nuclear power stations. At Torness Power Station, accurate monitoring of sludge and supernatant levels within Active Effluent Treatment Plant (AETP) tanks is essential to maintaining process control and meeting environmental obligations.
As part of ongoing lifecycle management, EDF identified the need to modernise its level measurement capability. The existing system, while historically effective, had reached a stage where long-term supportability and maintainability were becoming increasingly constrained.
This created an opportunity to not only replace legacy instrumentation, but to improve measurement performance and establish a consistent approach that could be deployed across multiple sites.
Overcoming a Complex Measurement Challenge in Multi-Phase Media
The challenge extended beyond simple instrumentation replacement. The AETP tanks contain a complex mixture of media, including water, ion exchange resins, graded sands, anthracite and sludge. Each layer presents different physical properties, making reliable interface detection technically demanding.
EDF required a solution that could:
- Accurately detect multiple material interfaces within a single tank
- Perform consistently in harsh and variable process conditions
- Avoid signal interference between adjacent instruments
- Be validated against representative operating conditions before deployment
In addition, all work needed to align with nuclear quality assurance requirements and be supported by robust evidence to satisfy regulatory scrutiny.

“There isn’t a single instrument that solves this kind of problem on its own. The key is understanding how different technologies behave together in real conditions.”
Project Manager, AMS Nuclear
Validating Performance Through Structured Testing and Collaboration
The testing phase was designed to build confidence through evidence.
AMS Nuclear conducted a comprehensive series of trials, including:
- Functional response testing across varying media compositions
- Assessment of sensor performance during insertion and removal
- Simulation of tank filling and draining conditions
- Verification of signal integrity when instruments operated in close proximity
- Extended soak testing to evaluate long-term behaviour in sludge environments
EDF personnel were involved throughout, witnessing key stages of testing and contributing to the evaluation process. This collaborative approach ensured alignment and transparency at every stage.
The outcome was a clear, evidence-based recommendation of the most suitable instrumentation configuration, supported by a detailed test report and defined pathway to deployment.
Creating a Platform for Fleet-Wide Standardisation and Long-Term Value
The success of the Torness trials established more than a single-site solution.
The validated design demonstrated that:
- Reliable measurement of complex, multi-phase media is achievable using integrated COTS technologies
- Instrumentation performance can be confidently predicted through representative testing
- A single engineered solution can be adapted for deployment across multiple stations
With further programmes already identified for other EDF sites, including Heysham 2, the project provides a foundation for a consistent, fleet-wide approach to sludge level monitoring.